Flashback: Angel vs Demon // Tongue vs Side-Mouth // Frontrunner vs Underdog

May 19, 2009

Whatever you want to name them, they’re the final 2, and they both deserve to be there. Adam Lambert, 27 (can you believe that??) and Kris Allen, 23, are the finalists for Season 8 of American Idol. In this -MDOC- special annual post, we’ll take you back to get a glimpse of their journey on American Idol.


Firstly, the auditions. Adam Lambert auditioned in San Francisco. He walked into the room already looking like a star (with less mascara). Adam sang Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody”, but it was too theatrical. The judges weren’t too keen on Adam, but he was already garnering a strong following along the way. We first saw (or rather, a little peep) Kris Allen in Louisville, where he sang “A Song For You”. We soon forgot Kris after 5 seconds. Of course, both made it through to Hollywood.

Adam: 1 || Kris: 0

Hollywood Round was next! Kris Allen appeared alongside best buddy Matt Giraud in the group rounds, where they formed a group with two others and dubbed themselves as “White Chocolate”. Their performance of “I Want You Back” was easily the best performance of the day. Adam Lambert joined forces with fellow top 36 contenders Matt Breitzke and Jesse Langseth, and  they performed “Some Kind of Wonderful”. It was good, but wasn’t really that memorable. The contestants then had to perform individually on Day 4. Adam Lambert didn’t really pull off his rendition of Cher’s “Believe”. At least he was shown, Kris Allen was no where to be seen. Both of them made it to the top 36. Even though he wasn’t really shown much, Kris gets a point for excelling in White Chocolate.

Adam: 1 || Kris: 1

Now to the top 36! Both finalists originated from Group 2 (along with 4 out of 5 of the top 5, indicating that Group 2 was certainly the best), which was so packed to the brim with talented contestants that we couldn’t really choose who to vote for. Kris Allen appeared, singing “Man In The Mirror”. We were all wondering, who was this guy? Yes we know he’s cute, but will looks get him so far? How did this cannon fodder end up in the top 36? He’ll be gone, that’s for sure. But lo and behold! Kris beat out favourites Megan Corkrey and Matt Giraud to round up the three finalists for Group 2. Hmm, maybe he got lucky with his good looks,  but he’ll be gone soon. Adam Lambert, of course, received the (first of many) pimp spot, and he did an unforgettable performance of “Satisfaction”. Unforgettable, because no one would forget all that screaming and fierce stomping around the stage. A new, fresh talent! Adam’s definitely getting votes. As expected, he got into the top 13 without any challenge at all. Adam wins this round. (A trivia! All four contestants who got the pimp spot during the top 36 made it through to the top 13, and all four of them ended in the top 7.)


Adam: 2 || Kris: 1

Time for the top 13! It was Michael Jackson Week. Kris Allen performed “Remember The Time”, while jamming it out on his guitar. His guitar didn’t really suited the song, but it definitely helped him to form an image of who Kris Allen was. Adam Lambert did “Black and White” and was given the title of best performance of the night. It was expected, since the whole theme was very theatrical anyways. Adam wins.


Adam: 3 || Kris: 1

Top 11! Country Week. Kris Allen was really smooth with his heartwarming performance of “To Make You Feel My Love”. Judges all loved it, Simon even hinted that Kris could win this (how right you are, Simon). And to the most infamous performance of the season, Adam Lambert‘s “Ring of Fire”.  He was  touching himself all over. Ummm, what? No one knew what to do, what to say, what to comment. Flabbergasted, hypnotized, starstruck, cat got our tongues? In the end, Simon made it clear for us: either you love it, or hate it. While Adam fans may love (or pretend to) it, the rest of us despised it.


Adam: 3 || Kris: 2

The Idols tackled Motown in the top 10. Kris Allen gave a forgettable rendition of “How Sweet It Is”, accompanied by his friend, the guitar. As usual, his guitar didn’t really help much. It was a clumsy performance. Judges didn’t like it. Adam Lambert was out to rule the world. This was the week where all the spotlights were on Adam, as he crooned “The Tracks of My Tears” in a classical suit and his hair slicked back. Girls were screaming, fans were voting. Adam was now the frontrunner of the competition, off to face Danny Gokey in the finals.


Adam: 4 || Kris: 2

Oooh, Adam is leading. Top 9 was Top Downloads Week. Adam Lambert got his hair combed back once more, and the high notes were back. Haven’t we seen and heard those before? Adam performed “Play That Funky Music”. Not a fan of it, it was a very typical performance, even for Adam.  Indulgent! Kris Allen finally got the pimped spot and ended the show beautifully with “Ain’t No Sunshine”, one of his best performance of the whole season. It was wonderfully done, with Kris behind the piano, and after it ended we were groaning wanting more. Artistry! (Trivia! “Artistry” and “Indulgent” were probably the most uttered word by Kara and Simon this season, and  are the most hated words used, chosen by fans.)


Adam: 4 || Kris: 3

The top 8 was next with the songs from the year they were born. Kris Allen tried to emulate Matt Giraud by singing in the mosh pit, but got the same bad reviews as well. Kris performed “All She Wants to Do Is Dance”, and was forgotten by the end of the night. His pulled out his guitar, and once again, it wasn’t useful at all, as he got drone out by all the music. Adam Lambert gave the best performance of the night, and probably the most talked about one of the whole season. He did “Mad World” superbly, with the dim lights and  minimal music in the background. It was all about his power vocals, and he pulled it off amazingly. It was very haunting and eerie. Simon announced that Adam was going to win. And at this point of the game, we all believed that as well.


Adam: 5 || Kris: 3

Top 7 Week, Songs from the Movies, was basically a trainwreck. Almost everyone gave sub-par performances, none outshining the other, it was all a snoozefest. Adam Lambert screamed another one, this time it was “Born To Be Wild”. It was getting kind of old. Next! Kris Allen gave one of his top performaces of the season, “Falling Slowly”. His vocals were very controlled, he did everything splendidly. Initially, I didn’t connect with his performance at all, but I can now say that it was one of his best.


Adam: 5 || Kris: 4

Disco Week was slotted in at the last minute for the theme for the top 7, since Matt Giraud was (deservingly) saved. Of course, being disco week, everyone was expecting Adam Lambert to have the upper hand and pull off another performance full of screaming and cheesy dance moves. But he surprised us once again, this time doing a slow march of “If I Can’t Have You”, portraying perfect emotion, which reduced Paula to tears. We all now know that this guy can do practically anything. Kris Allen caused heads to turn by shopping in the women’s department and giving an acoustic version of “She Works Hard For Money”. It was fresh, current and great. Of course, it had absolutely nothing to do with the theme. But do we or the judges care? No. Kara was all about her artistry crap as usual, but this we can agree on: Kris was starting to define himself as an acoustic/guitar/pop/soul artist. And we really liked that.


Adam: 5 || Kris: 5

The top 5 delivered the best week of the season with Jazz Week. Kris Allen did a slow, mid-tempo performance of “The Way You Look Tonight”, and it was really really good. His vocals were spot on, and the way he switched keys while singing was beautiful. Plus his studio recording is a track that you can replay over and over again without getting tired of it. Even though it’s the top 5, we still haven’t crossed Kris Allen off yet as one of the contestants who could easily be sent home. But again, he prevailed. Adam Lambert strutted down the huge staircase in the middle of the stage in his immaculate white suit, singing “Feeling Good”. While his voice was impeccable, it wasn’t really that great. Same ol’. Seen there, heard that. Adam caused an “uproar” when he landed in the bottom 3. Oops, Adam is losing steam! He peaked too soon, and was going downhill. Both get points for doing great. (Trivia! Kris and Adam have both landed in the bottom 3  only once, and this was the week. Hmmm, what a coincidence!)


Adam: 6 || Kris: 6

Rock Week was the theme for the top 4, perfectly suited for Adam Lambert. He was the first contestant in Idol history to perform a Led Zeppelin song. Adam performed “Whole Lotta Love” exactly as any other rock star would have. Props all around. He was really comfortable on the stage. Later, he received the pimped spot once again, duetting with Allison Iraheta, who was eliminated on the same week. The duo pulled off an amazing performance of “Slow Ride”, and was easily the best performance of the night. It was so full of energy you could feed off it while watching. Kris Allen didn’t gave up, albeit his pissed off face, he managed to survive another week by performing “Come Together”, and later, “Renegade” with Danny Gokey. Both performances weren’t that good, they were only average. Rock is not doing good for Allen. No no.


Adam: 7 || Kris: 6

The top 3’s race to the finale was closer than ever. While everyone was still thinking that Kris Allen was the weakest link, Danny Gokey was (rightfully) sent home instead. Kris performed two songs, the first was “Apologize”, which was incredibly average, nothing new. However, his second performance, an acoustic cover of “Heartless”, totally won us over. It was hands down one of the best performance of the season. It was exactly the sort of music you would want to hear blasting out of your car radio while driving on the road. As Simon put it, it redeemed him, and gave him a spot in the final 2. Adam Lambert on the other hand was starting to wane and gave only decent, not great, performances of “One” and “Cryin'”. (Trivia! Adam has had the pimped spot for a total of FIVE times this season, probably higher than any other contestants ever had on the show. And a majority of his performances were positioned at the second half of the show, making Adam one of the most (if not the most) pimped contestant ever in Idol history.)


Adam: 7 || Kris: 7

They’re neck in neck! So who will win? Let’s give an extra point so that a winner will be chosen! Adam Lambert came into the show with loads of coverage, and was pimped throughout the show, gave outstanding performances week after week, hit insane and extremely high notes, getting rave reviews from the judges and the media, dubbed as a frontrunner, being a revolution and inspiration for being a gay contestant, garnering huge fans since the beginning,  has good looks, and even appearing on a magazine cover. Kris Allen on the other hand, came into the show with almost ZERO coverage and pimping, was dubbed as a cannon folder, constantly being called the underdog, constantly being underrated, picked up a massive following along the way, has good looks, can play instruments, is current, relevant, was only in the bottom 3 once and still managed to land in the finals.

From my point of view, Kris definitely worked really hard to get to the end. Kris is gaining momentum and picking up steam now, his fire isn’t about to go out anytime soon. I feel that Adam has peaked too soon and is now starting to be overshadowed. Maybe people are getting tired of Adam. But one thing is for sure, Kris has a shot at winning this. Note that last week, the top 2 was separated by a mere ONE MILLION VOTES. That is not a huge margin! If it was Adam who was leading Kris by a million votes, that means that Kris is sneaking up on Adam and can easily win it all. If it was Kris who was leading the pack, that means that Kris is already on his way to the win. Besides, Kris will be getting most of the votes from Danny’s fans, since the latter was eliminated last week. And Danny’s fanbase is HUGE, so that will  help boost the numbers.

Adam: 7 || Kris: 8


Therefore, unless Adam produces another heart-stopping performance tomorrow, I am fairly confident that Kris has this in the bag. This is probably the closest finale ever. We say that every year, don’t we? Hehe.

I don’t know about you guys, but I’m ready for the underdog to sweep the crown under the frontrunner and take it all.


I hereby announce Kris Allen as the winner of American Idol 2009.

Hey, what do you know? “Falling Slowly” is currently playing on my iTunes. 😉

What do you think? Who will win it all? Please leave comments!



  1. Kris Allen will NOT win! I like you’re little match up thing, but Adam is going to win. There has never been more hype over an American Idol than Adam Lambert. People in CHINA even love Adam Lambert. WHEN he win, he will be one of the BIGGEST American Idols ever!!

  2. Hmm, I concur on the fact that they’re both good, but my AmIdol this year will always be Matty G ❤ Can’t wait to see him during the results show!

    • I agree, Matty G is the best. ♥

  3. ROFLMAO. My sentiments exactly 😉

  4. While Adam fans may love (or pretend to) it, the rest of us despised it. -> u sure? no clues for ur conclusion. My friend likes Danny but she’s thrilled by “Ring of fire”.

    Ur flashback is too biased cuz u like Kris better than Adam. Kris does have couple of good songs however no one can deny Adam’s much better.

    Only one thing i can agree with u is that Kris might win cuz he has votes from Danny’s fans. But que sera sera, let it be until the result comes out.

    As Simon said ‘the aim of the competition is finding a star’ yet Adam is already a star with his inborn talent. No matter he wins the show or not, he wins my heart!

  5. yup, you do sound wayyyyy to biasedly supporting kris..

    everyone knows adam’s got mad talent.. and he deserves the title more than kris..

    and as azurie said, kris’ only hope of winning is by getting danny’s votes..

    i do hope adam comes out victorious.. =) =)

  6. this sounds very biased. i can’t believe the blogger. adam deserves every praise the judges gave him. he’s the only idol in ai history, i believe, that gives us viewers the entertainment we need. kris allen is good but nothing compare to adam. when i watch him perform i thought that he’s always pitchy. i hope adam wins this thing.

  7. I’m all for Kris sweeping away the title. Even if he doesn’t win, I’ll still think he was more deserving since he was one of those people who shone all the brighter much later in the show. But then again, I have to say that if we’re really talking about being an ‘Idol’ then Adam has it all. The bling, the things, the glitz and the glamour.. he’s more suited to be an ‘American Idol’ per se – wowing people with his over-the-top antics till he fizzles out or people get sick.

    Kris however, is going to last.

    This reminds me of last season. I hoped Cook wouldn’t win, because I was worried he’d get influenced (which he didn’t, thankfully) but I wanted him to win because he was fantastic. So confusing. *dazed* But thinking too much aside, I’m glad Cook won, and I’ll be damn glad if Kris takes this year’s crown too.

    PS: Katy Perry was totally uncool, pimping Adam like that -_- It made me write off her entire performance. Boo.

  8. I don’t think I can find a single thing in there that I don’t agree with you on.

    I think Kris really deserves to win this. While Adam’s vocal abilities are lightyears ahead of his, I think he picks better songs. Also, he doesn’t overdo his performances. I could barely watch “Cryin'” and “Born To Be Wild” because I thought they were exaggerated and annoying.

    Kris might not be able to pull another “Heartless” out of the bag for tonight, but he may not have to. Like you said, I think many people are getting tired of Adam. I definitely am. He was one of my clear favorites in the Top 13, but then Kris got better and better and showed more versatility while Adam usually did the same old boring thing.

    Also, Kris goes last tonight.
    GO KRIS!


    I second that. Honestly think KRIS deserves to win. I am getting very tired of Adam’s theatrical antics. Kris will ultimately win this. He has the charm, versatility and such a beautiful voice which as Paula says, he imprints to every song he sings. Clearly, without a doubt, he wins the crown.


  10. Your commentary is pretty biased against Kris, I’m just not going to lie about that. You have to admit that from day one, Adam has been consistent with giving a good effort. Kris was the unforgettable contestant that slid by week after week until he did a less than a handful of good songs. Gokey should have been in the final and I hope Adam wins because he’s not a screamer he’s a singer with an amazing range and impressive vocal control.

    I hope Aamerica makes the right the decision based on true talent, not popularity/image.

  11. I’m totally disagree with you.

    I think that Kris has talent and he has a future on the music business but, Adam has more talent. It’s a singing competition, not a “who’s-more-popular” competition or “who’s-less-polemic” competition. Kris has the christian and Red State vote. Adam has the gay/jewish and Blue State vote. They’re really close to be the winners

    Adam has the 1 million votes extra, and you said that Kris is sneaking up on Adam and can easily win it all, but, if the Danny voters go to Adam, it will be different.

    The results can change in any minute. And, let me ad this:


    Adam: 8 || Kris: 8

    It’s tied

    They’re already famous and talented. It doesn’t matter who win this. Adam is already a winner and Kris is already a winner.

    Anyway… Adam FTW

  12. I’m really for Kris since he did not get enough coverage prior to top 36 to create superfanbases like those of Danny and Adam’s.

    I feel triumphant everytime an underdog wins the whole thing. That’s the real victory, I must say!

    Kudos to Kris coz he really gave a good fight despite massive popularity by his competitors. Just smoothsailing throughout the competition, He made Kara’s “crap” song sound better!

  13. I think you are too biased about this because you like Kris better than Adam, I think Adam deserves a point for “If I Can’t Have You” and for “One”. Those were two of the best of the season.

    Kris is too inconsistent. He gives a great performance every no and then, but he also screws up on a lot, just like in the top 3. One was spectacular and the other was just… just… average

    I think Adam should win because he has shown us his stuff from the very beginning and he has never given a bad performance that everyone will forget. He has been the most consistent contestant all year long and he has shown us that he can rock (obviously) and that he can also tone down a bit like in “Mad World”, THE best performance of the season.

    Anyways, Thanks for uploading the songs and letting us download them. Hope your back for the finale and for next year…


  14. I love your reviews, but I have to agree… Man, you are way bias towards Kris.

    I agree with most of the points except on one, during the disco week. It is so clear that Adam’s redention of If I can’t have you is one of the best and definitely much much better than Kris’s song.

    And since I watched the finale, It simply has to be Adam who wins the competition! Hands down.

  15. I was a HUGE fan of Adam Lambert in the beginning. I couldn’t even remember who Kris Allen was. But now, I’ve gotten tired of Adam, and I really want Kris to win.

    He deserves it. He works hard for the money xD

    • What kind of fan are u? :)) HUGE? :)) How sarcastic! Anyway, it’s ur choice.

  16. i really hope your predictions are right again!

    absolutely sick of adam-types winning idol.

    i love how kris is so understated and humble.

  17. Adam is every bit as humble as Kris. He never once came across as arrogant and always accepted whatever comments he got gracefully, which is an incredible feat. You’d think after all the incredible comments he’s received, he’d be incredibly arrogant. But he isn’t! He’s thanked the band once or twice too, if I’m not wrong.

    And I honestly don’t think Kris wants to win as much as Adam does. Every single performance Adam does, you can tell he’s singing it to win (and I’m not saying this because he has an insane vocal range). I mean, even Simon has mentioned how Adam is singing to win.

    And don’t forget star quality. Adam’s just really confident in the way he holds himself, which is something I feel Kris lacks.

    With that being said, I think Kris will win, because of his fan-base (plus Danny’s), but here’s to hoping that Adam will take that crown anyway.

  18. i don’t think the post is biased. shame on you to even say so. i mean, it’s raph’s blog. don’t like it? make your own.

    anyhow, i’m for kris allen, too. well, i think i’ve established that already. hehe.

    i agree with everything in here from the words “whatever” to “iTunes”! LOL. 🙂 nice. i’m amazed by how you remember all of this.

    so, i’m not making this any longer. to wrap this comment up and to add my conlusion: to Kris haters, boo you. to his fans, cheers! [: KRIS FTW PEOPLE!

    *i love this post (and blog). a lot. ♥ thanks! i’ll miss reading your AI reviews. 🙂

    rockin’ out, RALPH

  19. kris really worked hard to be in that position so i think he deserves to win!

    adam came to that position effortlessly! but in the process i think people became tired of his screaming whereas kris always puts on something new week after week.. so yeah. i agree with raph. kris might win this:)

  20. Your post title rocks! hehe

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: